A few months after I first met Mark in college, we ran into each other in a campus dining hall. As we chatted, he admired my high school class ring. I held my hand out to let him see it more closely, and peering down at the ring, he said, “Would you mind taking it off?” So, I took off my ring and handed it to him, expecting that he wanted to look at it more closely still. To my utter astonishment, he simply said “thank you,” pocketed the ring and walked away. I stood there in the lobby, open-mouthed and paralyzed with wonder, like a newly carved statue. Had this man just stolen my ring? Was this a joke? Had he taken it to show it to someone else? Was he intending to come back? What did he mean by it? What kind of person does something so odd and unexpected? And what on earth do I do now?

Fortunately, Mark’s roommate, who had witnessed the interaction, approached me. “Come on,” he said wearily, as if this sort of thing happened all the time, “Let’s go get your ring back.” He led me, mute and meek, through the building until we finally found Mark in a game room, playing pool. “Mark,” said his roommate, extending a palm, “the ring…” Mark smiled at me, looking both sly and awkward, as he handed over the ring, and I knew then that it had been a joke and that he was disappointed that I didn’t (or didn’t know how to) play along.

Eventually, I got used to Mark’s odd tricks, spontaneous decisions, sudden new interests and chance conversations. He’d point over my shoulder and say brightly “Look over there!” while deftly swiping whatever was in front of me and seeing how long it took me to notice. We’d walk down the street, discussing what flavor we thought of when someone said “milkshake,” and when we differed, he’d stop the next five random passersby to ask what they thought, as if he were Jay Leno and I were his camera. He’d decide he’d want to learn Russian or juggling or how to play the recorder. He’d strike up a conversation with a strange couple at the next table in a restaurant and leave with their phone numbers. I’d say I was thirsty, and he’d run out of the dormitory, returning with a plastic champagne glass from the cafeteria filled with soda and a flower from the nearest accessible blooming plant.

And I greeted it all with a mix of delighted awe and nagging discomfort. I loved that he did these crazy things that I was too scared, too shy, too bound by rules, too afraid of failure to do myself, and as I grew used to him, little by little, I started to feel more comfortable with spontaneity and novelty both in him and in myself, which I thought was a good thing. Yet I’d often find myself appalled and apologetic. “Yes, I’m sorry he took your coffee cup. It was a joke. He does those things,” and like Mark’s roommate had, I learned to take care of the people he startled or embarrassed or to tie up the loose ends he left straying behind him like jester’s ribbons.

When, years later, he admitted to his sex addiction, much of that spontaneity didn’t seem like fun anymore. I started to see that some of his tricks and jokes were ways to test people’s limits, that collecting contact numbers wasn’t always in the name of friendship and that he hadn’t taken Russian so much from a sudden passion for the language as a sudden passion for a Russian classmate. And in an attempt to protect myself from more hurt, I started to wall off and become even more of a compulsive planner, even more rigid about rules, even more strict about structure, even more wedded to routine than I ever had been before.

Spontaneity is still extremely difficult for me. The other night Mark came home after the kids were asleep and said, “Honey, I’d like to take a shower and then make love to you.” And as he showered, my mind raced: “That’s not right! That’s different. It’s supposed to be make love first and then take a shower. That’s the way it always has been. Has he been with someone else? Is that why he wants to take a shower first?” For a moment, I was as paralyzed as the first time he took my ring and walked away. What did he mean by it? What kind of person does something so odd and unexpected? And what on earth do I do now?

But I have a new guide within me now. One that gently led me to see that a shower was hardly a purloined ring, and not being able to tolerate even so small a change in routine without pain is the damage of disease. But it also led me to see that the gift of recovery is being able to talk to my husband honestly about it rather than pretending the fear and anxiety don’t exist (because they “shouldn’t”). And I trust that eventually, as my recovery continues, my need for that protective wall of structure will slowly slip away into balance with a new and healthy spontaneity.