Why aren’t you skinny?
Sep 3, 08- (by Blackout Girl)
- 9 responses

- Family and Friends, Mind, Body, Spirit, Sober Salon, Young and Sober

I was on the treadmill this morning running my morning mile when my parents woke up and came downstairs to join me. I felt good, having run a good mile in a decent time and decided to join them outside. They were in town for a night on their way home from Baltimore. I was doing my little dumbbell routine that I do every morning on the deck while they were sitting and pulling on their morning cigarette.
My father looks at me and said, “Ya know Jennifer, I don’t understand, you work out everyday and you don’t eat a lot. Why aren’t you skinny?”
I felt like I had been punched in the stomach. “Gee, Dad thanks for the shot of self esteem this morning.” Is what I thought. Instead of saying that of course I started making excuses for why I wasn’t “skinny” I am only 5’3, my body type is more athletic etc. All of this followed by my mother quickly sticking up for me and then a nice awkward pause. My father then said well there was a time when you were skinny. I blurted out “Well Dad, that was only when I was bulimic and very sick in my disease. This is my body healthy and it is what it is. I will never be a skinny girl.” That ended the conversation. My father knows of my illnesses, for crying out loud he lived and read the book!!!! He knows that I was horribly bulimic. He knows that I lived on cocaine rather than solid meals. It amazes me that he would still say stuff like that to me after all these years and all that we have been through!
As I got ready for work and looked in the mirror, I began critiquing every aspect of my appearance and found myself just disgusted. I had to catch myself quickly before I let those old tapes begin to play in my head. “You’re not good enough, you’re fat, you’re ugly” those tapes that use to drive me to mistreat my body, to binge and purge and self loathe.
It is so sad to me that still after 33 years I can allow another person to influence the way I feel about myself. Having my father says these things to me of course adds a whole extra layer of hurt to it. I am not a fat girl! I am a beautiful woman. I decided a while ago that I will take care of my body.
I run.
I do Yoga etc.
But I will not diet; I refuse to count calories, weigh my food, attempt fads, and take pills or anything else.
Instead, I honor my stomach; I listen to it and feed it when it is hungry.
I do not deny myself of urges nor do I overindulge. I simply eat what I like. This comes at a sacrifice yes but I am happy most of the time. In order for me to be a size four, I have to starve myself and deny myself the foods I enjoy. While that may offer me an occasionally jump for joy when I can slip on my skinny jeans with ease—it still sucks to give up so much.
God, I have already given up so much! I don’t eat meat, I don’t drink soda, I gave up alcohol, drugs etc.
By working out and eating what I want I stay around a size six. In my humble opinion, a size six is pretty damn good given that the average woman is a size twelve! I thank god that I am in recovery and have tools to deal with statements like this because twelve years ago what my father said to me would have sent me down a path of self destruction that would have been anything but healthy.
Leave a response! All your responses matter, so say whatever you want. But please refrain from spamming and shameless plugs, as well as excessive use of vulgar language. Please refer to our Code of Conduct.





Okay, I just finished writing in our new ‘Food Issues, Anyone?’ group–go to chat groups and click on that title–we’d love to have you join us! I can so relate to this post. I have struggled with eating disorder stuff my whole life. I am soooo much better than i was, but i still have that monkey on my back. I happen to be at my parents’ and my mother continually focuses on my weight as she has my whole life. I am finally able to see that this is her issue, not mine. I’m relatively happy with who I am and how I look at this point–relatively. ;)–thanks to my daughter (somehow i won’t model bad behavior around food with her) and an awesome guy who tells me again and again that he likes me just the way I am. I know its ‘an inside job’, but maybe the combo is actually working. Thanks for your honesty.
I’m glad that you are realizing that it’s not what others say about us, it’s how we feel about ourselves. It’s a cheap shot but perhaps your dad doesn’t look the same as he did 10 years ago. Bodies change with age and with insight into what is really important. You sound like you are healthy and have a good attitude.
The way you handled that rough comment from you dad sounds so good. Setting boundaries with my parents and their unreasonable ideas about how I should live my life has been something I’m really enjoying in recovery. It’s hard as hell, but it feels good when it works.
I wonder why it acceptable to comment on a skinny chicks weight, but never someone who is overweight??? I have always been skinny and people comment on my weight ALL THE TIME!
Good on you for taking care of yourself (I wish I could say the same. I’m underweight but I don’t exercise and I have a massive chocolate addiction. Oh well). I am always happy to see a female with a healthy perspective!
Amy makes an excellent point! Thanks, Amy! I love that! I am athletic and have always been thin. When I am training, I get even thinner, but not unhealthy! I am not underweight by a million miles, but I look thin, and people constantly comment on it with that “you must not be healthy if you are that thin” tone of voice. I find myself rationalizing my HEALTHY weight just as you found yourself rationalizing your healthy weight with your father. It sucks from both sides.
You handled your father’s comment very nicely. Keep setting those boundaries and one day his behavior will no longer bring him the reward he is searching out–and it may actually stop! Keep up the healthy exercise and eating! Neither are easy to do in this world!
I think it’s cultural, going back to the days (less than a century ago) when thin often did mean unhealthy. I heard it from people when I was a 6′3″, 185 lb. college distance swimmer back in the ’60’s, and that’s a BMI of 23, smack in the middle of today’s normal range. (Hope to see that again some day, but it’s a long row to hoe.)
You hear it also in reference to babies. People are always complimenting moms on their cute chubby babies, not realizing that the child is being set up for a lifetime of fighting all those cute little fat cells. I’ve even heard doctors do it.
Thank you everyone for your comments. I love being in a place where I can speak freely and get such incredible insight and support. This is what I love most about recovery!!!
You could be fat, and still be beautiful..the two things are not mutually exclusive. Our culture is sick with fatphobia, and fatness is equated with ugliness, laziness and moral degeneration. Look at how you put it up there: “I am not a fat girl! I am a beautiful woman.”
I know this is a hard question, but why is it “good” that you are a size six when the “average” woman is a size 12. I wear a size 18, I do yoga and take dance classes and I run 4 miles on the elliptical 3 times a week. Does my size make me more or less “good” than you? It’s a strange mindset that we have, this equating of size with worth.
Here’s the thing: weight is morally neutral.
Good for you that you’re not dieting or doing any disordered eating. I’ve been there and I know how hard it is.
It is good for my body type to not be over a size six. It is not healthy for me to be heavier than that with my body type that is why for me it is healthy, beautiful and good. I have been a size twelve in my life before and I was not healthy or taking care of my body in anyway. I have also been a size two and again was not healthy or taking care of my body at all. I think it is all about finding your healthy weight–the one your body naturally comes too when you are eating right, exercising regularily and still enjoying life and not denying yourself all the time. You are correct, beautiful is relative.
I don’t equate “fat” with any particular size really. I think it is more the way you take care of yourself. When I hear the word “fat” I think of those who are grossly obese, unhealthy and not doing anything about it. So in my mind fat and beautiful can be mutually exclusive. Just like “skinny” isn’t always beautiful because it could be grossly underweight and unhealthy. The important question to ask ourselves is “Are you healthy for your body type?” We cannot deny that we have a significant obesity problem in this country and I feel that people have a responsiblity to set good moral standards. Eating right and working out are important things that every person should be doing.